Andrew’s Diner

Nestled on bustling Hylan Boulevard in Staten Island, Andrew’s Diner is a cherished local gem that perfectly captures the essence of a classic American diner while delivering an impressive menu that caters to all tastes. Whether you’re craving a hearty breakfast, a satisfying lunch, or a comforting dinner, this diner offers a warm, inviting atmosphere that feels like a home away from home.

Andrew’s Diner serves up an extensive variety of dishes that highlight diner favorites alongside inventive twists that elevate the experience. Start your day with morning delights such as the fluffy Silver Dollar Pancakes drizzled with real maple syrup—an authentic touch that delighted one satisfied guest—and the perfectly cooked Spinach & Cheese Omelette or the customizable Create Your Own Omelette for a personalized breakfast. For those who prefer hearty comfort, items like the Chicken and Waffles and the legendary Yankee Pot Roast provide generous portions packed with rich, satisfying flavors.

If lunch or dinner is your goal, the menu shines just as brightly. The Pastrami Sandwich and the Classic Cuban Sandwich serve as crowd-pleasers, boasting tender, flavorful meats stacked on fresh breads. For a unique combination, the Pizza Burger with French Fries brings together two favorites into one mouthwatering creation. Salad lovers aren’t left out, with options like the crisp Greek Salad with Grilled Chicken and the refreshing Waldorf Salad with Grilled Chicken providing a light, vibrant alternative.

What truly sets Andrew’s Diner apart is its perfect balance of quality, portion size, and genuine hospitality. The atmosphere radiates the nostalgic charm of a classic diner, with cozy seating and a well-kept, clean environment that instantly puts you at ease. Reviewers frequently mention the friendly and attentive staff, with special praise for servers like Kim, whose warmth complements the fantastic food. Customers appreciate the speedy, smooth service even when the place is bustling, underscoring a commitment to making every guest feel valued.

Dining at Andrew’s Diner also means diving into comforting side options like a fresh fruit cup or golden brown toast and enjoying breakfast specials that go beyond the ordinary—think Corned Beef Hash & Eggs or the hearty Ham & Cheese Omelette. With cold cereal and oatmeal available, there’s something for early risers craving a lighter start too.

Customers repeatedly celebrate the diner’s generous portions and authentic taste, with one visitor expressing delight over perfectly crisp, fluffy waffles served with sugar-free syrup, demonstrating the kitchen’s attentiveness to individual preferences. The cozy, classic vibe embellished by a Staten Island mural gives each visit a local flavor that enhances the overall experience.

For anyone seeking a quintessential, no-fuss diner in Staten Island where delicious food meets genuine care and a welcoming ambiance, Andrew’s Diner stands out. It’s the kind of place that invites you to linger over a comforting plate, share stories with friends, and leave feeling completely satisfied and taken care of.